Skip to content
  • About Us
    • About CCRC
    • CCRC Staff
    • Advisory Board
    • Biennial Report
    • Employment
    • Contact
    • About CCRC
    • CCRC Staff
    • Advisory Board
    • Biennial Report
    • Employment
    • Contact
  • News
    • CCRC in the News
    • Opinion
    • Press Releases
    • CCRC in the News
    • Opinion
    • Press Releases
  • Community College FAQs
  • Research Areas
    • Dual Enrollment
    • Developmental Education
    • Guided Pathways
    • Advising & Student Supports
    • Teaching & Learning
    • Transfer
    • Workforce Education
    • Dual Enrollment
    • Developmental Education
    • Guided Pathways
    • Advising & Student Supports
    • Teaching & Learning
    • Transfer
    • Workforce Education
  • Publications
  • Blog
  • Resources
    • Policy Resources
    • Guided Pathways Workshops
    • Policy Resources
    • Guided Pathways Workshops
  • More
    • Events
    • Research Projects
    • Events
    • Research Projects
  • Overview
  • Important Dates
  • FAQs
  • Overview
  • Important Dates
  • FAQs
  • Overview
  • Important Dates
  • FAQs

The False Dichotomy Between Academic Learning and Occupational Skills

By Thomas Bailey & Clive Belfield

What distinctions are there between vocational (career and technical) education and academic learning in college? In this essay, researchers compare broad academic and vocational program goals, embodied skills, tasks, and jobs, with a focus primarily on community college students.

There is considerable overlap between the two types of education, so a separation of tracks presents a false dichotomy. In addition, vocational certificates, which often have little academic content, have attracted attention lately as a path to good jobs. New evidence indicates that degrees offer more substantial advantages than certificates in the labor market.

Researchers argue for an alternative framework for thinking about the optimal accumulation of skills in college. Rejecting the traditional distinction between vocational education and academic learning, they posit that educational paths are best understood as accumulations of general education, followed by terminal work-related education. Researchers label this the Gen-Tech framework and consider its explanatory power and implications for colleges and students.

Download Links

View article (subscription may be required)
September 2019

Related Publications

May 2018

Responding to Divergent Trends: Vocational and Transfer Education at Community Colleges

December 2015

What About Certificates? Evidence on the Labor Market Returns to Non-Degree Community College Awards in Two States

Additional Resources

For more policy briefs and fact sheets, visit CCRC’s Policy Resources page.

Stay in Touch!

Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest on our research, including publications, blog posts, and upcoming events.
Subscribe

Community College Research Center, Teachers College, Columbia University
Box 174 | 525 West 120th Street, New York, NY 10027

  • 212.678.3091
  • ccrc@columbia.edu
Facebook-f Twitter Linkedin Youtube Instagram

© 2025. All rights reserved.

RESEARCH AREAS

  • Dual Enrollment
  • Developmental Education
  • Guided Pathways
  • Advising & Student Supports
  • Teaching & Learning
  • Transfer
  • Workforce Education
  • Dual Enrollment
  • Developmental Education
  • Guided Pathways
  • Advising & Student Supports
  • Teaching & Learning
  • Transfer
  • Workforce Education
  • CC FAQs
  • About CCRC
  • Biennial Report
  • CCRC Staff
  • Employment
  • CC FAQs
  • About CCRC
  • Biennial Report
  • CCRC Staff
  • Employment
  • Publications
  • Blog
  • Policy Resources
  • Events
  • Publications
  • Blog
  • Policy Resources
  • Events
  • About Us
    • About CCRC
    • CCRC Staff
    • Advisory Board
    • Biennial Report
    • Employment
    • Contact
  • Research Areas
    • Dual Enrollment
    • Developmental Education
    • Guided Pathways
    • Advising & Student Supports
    • Teaching & Learning
    • Transfer
    • Workforce Education
  • Publications
  • Blog
  • Community College FAQs
  • News
    • CCRC in the News
    • Opinion
    • Press Releases
  • More
    • Events
    • Guided Pathways Workshops
    • Policy Resources
    • Research Projects