Skip to content
  • About Us
    • About CCRC
    • CCRC Staff
    • Research Affiliates
    • Advisory Board
    • Biennial Report
    • Employment
    • Contact
    • About CCRC
    • CCRC Staff
    • Research Affiliates
    • Advisory Board
    • Biennial Report
    • Employment
    • Contact
  • News
  • Community College FAQs
  • Research Areas
    • Dual Enrollment
    • Developmental Education
    • Guided Pathways
    • Advising & Student Supports
    • Teaching & Learning
    • Transfer
    • College to Career
    • Dual Enrollment
    • Developmental Education
    • Guided Pathways
    • Advising & Student Supports
    • Teaching & Learning
    • Transfer
    • College to Career
  • Publications
  • Blog
  • Resources
    • Policy Resources
    • Guided Pathways Workshops
    • Policy Resources
    • Guided Pathways Workshops
  • More
    • Events
    • Research Projects
    • Events
    • Research Projects
  • Overview
  • Important Dates
  • FAQs
  • Overview
  • Important Dates
  • FAQs
  • Overview
  • Important Dates
  • FAQs

Evaluating For-Profit Higher Education: Evidence From the Education Longitudinal Study

By Vivian Yuen Ting Liu & Clive Belfield

This CAPSEE working paper evaluates the postsecondary and labor market outcomes of students who attended for-profit colleges. The evaluation complements a similar study by Deming, Goldin, and Katz (2012) that found significant differences in outcomes between students in for-profit colleges and those in other sectors. In this study, the authors used the Education Longitudinal Study of 2002, a nationally representative survey monitoring the transitions of young people who were 10th graders in 2002, and compared outcomes during the college years and up to age 26.

In accord with Deming et al., the authors found adverse levels of borrowing and some evidence of wage penalties for students who attended a for-profit college. Paradoxically, however, these results are not associated with lower attainment levels, and there is little evidence that for-profit students were less satisfied with their college experience. The results hold even with detailed controls for ability, alternative comparison groups, controls for selection into the for-profit sector, and alternative designations of for-profit college enrollment. However, the combined effect of higher borrowing and lower earnings for students at for-profit colleges is substantial, such that the average returns to community college dominate those at for-profit colleges.

  • Center for Analysis of Postsecondary Education and Employment (CAPSEE)

Download Links

Download CAPSEE working paper
September 2014

Related Publications

November 2019

The Labor Market Returns to For-Profit Higher Education: Evidence for Transfer Students

April 2006

Defending the Community College Equity Agenda

Additional Resources

For more policy briefs and fact sheets, visit CCRC’s Policy Resources page.

Stay in Touch!

Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest on our research, including publications, blog posts, and upcoming events.
Subscribe

Community College Research Center, Teachers College, Columbia University
Box 174 | 525 West 120th Street, New York, NY 10027

  • 212.678.3091
  • ccrc@columbia.edu
Facebook-f Twitter Linkedin Youtube Instagram

© 2025. All rights reserved.

RESEARCH AREAS

  • Dual Enrollment
  • Developmental Education
  • Guided Pathways
  • Advising & Student Supports
  • Teaching & Learning
  • Transfer
  • College to Career
  • Dual Enrollment
  • Developmental Education
  • Guided Pathways
  • Advising & Student Supports
  • Teaching & Learning
  • Transfer
  • College to Career
  • Community College FAQs
  • About CCRC
  • Biennial Report 24-26
  • CCRC Staff
  • Employment
  • Community College FAQs
  • About CCRC
  • Biennial Report 24-26
  • CCRC Staff
  • Employment
  • Publications
  • Blog
  • Policy Resources
  • Events
  • Publications
  • Blog
  • Policy Resources
  • Events
  • About Us
    • About CCRC
    • CCRC Staff
    • Research Affiliates
    • Advisory Board
    • Biennial Report 24-26
  • Research Areas
    • Dual Enrollment
    • Developmental Education
    • Guided Pathways
    • Advising & Student Supports
    • Teaching & Learning
    • Transfer
    • College to Career
  • Publications
  • Blog
  • Community College FAQs
  • News
  • More
    • Guided Pathways Workshops
    • Policy Resources
    • Research Projects
    • Events
  • About Us
    • About CCRC
    • CCRC Staff
    • Research Affiliates
    • Advisory Board
    • Biennial Report 24-26
  • Research Areas
    • Dual Enrollment
    • Developmental Education
    • Guided Pathways
    • Advising & Student Supports
    • Teaching & Learning
    • Transfer
    • College to Career
  • Publications
  • Blog
  • Community College FAQs
  • News
  • More
    • Guided Pathways Workshops
    • Policy Resources
    • Research Projects
    • Events